Best dog chew toys comparison
Power chewers can quickly shred “indestructible” toys. To help you find a durable option that suits your dog’s chewing style, we’ve compared five of the toughest toys on the market. Use the table below to see how each toy differs in material, shape and suitability.
Comparison table
| Feature | KONG Extreme | Goughnuts Ring | West Paw Hurley | Nylabone Power Chew | Benebone Wishbone |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Dense natural rubber | Durable rubber with safety indicator | BPA‑free Zogoflex rubber | Tough flavoured nylon | Nylon infused with real flavours |
| Shape | Hollow cone | Ring | Bone‑shaped stick | Bone style | Wishbone shape |
| Best for | Power chewers needing mental stimulation | Dogs that need an ultra‑tough toy with wear indicator | Fetch, water play and moderate chewers | Dogs that prefer a traditional bone | Dogs that enjoy flavour and a unique grip |
| Safety & durability | Bounces away; stuffable to prolong chew time | Red core shows when to replace; lifetime guarantee | Floats; dishwasher safe; guaranteed durable | Solid design; supervise and replace once worn | Easy to hold; replace when ends show wear |
| Check price on Chewy | See options on Chewy | Check price on Chewy | View deal on Chewy | See Benebone on Chewy |
KONG Extreme
- MaterialDense natural rubber
- ShapeHollow cone
- Best forPower chewers needing mental stimulation
- Safety & durabilityBounces away; stuffable to prolong chew time
Goughnuts Ring
- MaterialDurable rubber with safety indicator
- ShapeRing
- Best forDogs that need an ultra‑tough toy with wear indicator
- Safety & durabilityRed core shows when to replace; lifetime guarantee
West Paw Hurley
- MaterialBPA‑free Zogoflex rubber
- ShapeBone‑shaped stick
- Best forFetch, water play and moderate chewers
- Safety & durabilityFloats; dishwasher safe; guaranteed durable
Nylabone Power Chew
- MaterialTough flavoured nylon
- ShapeBone style
- Best forDogs that prefer a traditional bone
- Safety & durabilitySolid design; supervise and replace once worn
Benebone Wishbone
- MaterialNylon infused with real flavours
- ShapeWishbone shape
- Best forDogs that enjoy flavour and a unique grip
- Safety & durabilityEasy to hold; replace when ends show wear
KONG Extreme
Made from ultra‑durable rubber, the KONG Extreme is hollow and can be stuffed with treats or kibble to keep power chewers engaged. Its unpredictable bounce adds excitement to games of fetch and encourages your dog to chew, lick and paw at it for longer.
Goughnuts Ring
The Goughnuts Ring is built for serious chewers. Its multi‑layer construction hides a red core that shows when it’s time to replace the toy. The ring design floats and can be rolled or tossed for interactive play, and it comes with a lifetime replacement guarantee from the manufacturer.
West Paw Hurley
Crafted from West Paw’s proprietary Zogoflex material, the Hurley is a flexible, floatable toy shaped like a bone. It’s dishwasher safe and made in the USA. The gentle yet durable rubber is easy on teeth and gums but tough enough to stand up to moderate power chewers.
Nylabone Power Chew
These strong nylon chews come in a variety of flavours and sizes. The classic bone shape is familiar to most dogs, and the textured surfaces can help clean teeth as your dog gnaws. Remember to replace the chew when the ends become worn or frayed.
See Nylabone Power Chew on Chewy
Benebone Wishbone
The Benebone Wishbone is made from durable nylon and infused with real food flavours. Its three‑pronged design makes it easy for dogs to hold in their paws. Choose from flavours like peanut butter and bacon, and always replace when worn.
See Benebone Wishbone on Chewy
Last updated: March 2026.