My Dog Destroys Every Toy: What to Check Next

By BestPetsCo Editorial Team · Last updated: September 18, 2026

Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission from purchases through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How affiliate links work.

Repeated toy damage is a reason to investigate size, activity and how your dog uses the toy. Buying a harder material without those checks can introduce different risks.

For product comparisons, check our indestructible dog toys or see the best toys for pitbulls.

Start with what happened to the last toy. Shredding fabric, emptying a food puzzle and biting pieces off rubber are different behaviors; none can be diagnosed from the label "power chewer" alone.

Quick Picks on Chewy

Start with the activity you need: food enrichment, supervised chewing, or fetch. No toy is indestructible.

* Editor's Pick

KONG Extreme

Natural rubber • stuffable • size to your dog

For supervised food-stuffing and chewing
Stuffable (helps redirect chewing)
Choose size up for heavy chewers

Check KONG Extreme price on Chewy ->

Benebone Wishbone

Hard nylon • paw-bracing shape • dental caution

Not for very strong or very aggressive chewers, per Benebone
Three-prong shape offers paw-bracing points
Follow the package size limit; supervise every use

See Benebone Wishbone on Chewy ->

Hurley has a solid Zogoflex bone-shaped body
Dishwasher safe
For fetch and supervised chewing; it has no food cavity

See West Paw Hurley on Chewy ->

Five checks before you buy again

Remove the damaged toy: set it aside so you can inspect it without the dog continuing to chew.
Check for missing material: if you think a fragment was swallowed, contact your veterinarian.
Record the model and size: check the exact weight band, age guidance and intended activity.
Describe the failure: note whether the dog tore a seam, chewed a hollow rim or wore down an end.
Choose the next activity: try a suitable supervised food task or retrieving game; do not automatically escalate to hard nylon.

Fast buying answer

If you just want the quickest "start here" toy list, go to: Best indestructible dog toys.

Use the failure pattern to narrow your next choice

Keep the toy label or a photo of it, and note how damage developed. This helps you ask the maker about a different size or design. It also prevents comparing a small food toy with a much larger solid chew as if only the brand changed.

Food interest: consider an appropriately sized hollow toy with an accessible filling.
Retrieving: choose a carryable fetch design and end the game when damage appears.
Chunk removal: stop that design and reassess before offering another chewing session.
Forceful biting: ask about dental suitability before choosing a rigid nylon product.

Affiliate note: some links may be affiliate links (no extra cost). We recommend only what fits this specific problem.

If chewing is destructive (walls, furniture, crates)

Then toys are only part of the picture. Use calm management and training basics here: How to stop destructive chewing.

Separate toy damage from a broader chewing problem

Use the checklist: Signs your dog is a power chewer. If chewing has changed suddenly, causes mouth injury, or includes repeated swallowing of non-food items, speak with your veterinarian rather than treating it as a shopping problem.

Sources: KONG damage and swallowed-fragment guidance, Benebone limitations, Goughnuts indicator differences and VCA dental guidance. These steps are based on published guidance; no BestPetsCo household toy test is claimed.

Compare designs Power Chewer Guide

Compare uses and limitations

These are design comparisons, not measured durability scores. Benebone is not intended for very strong or very aggressive chewers.

#	Product	Best for	Material	Size check	Limitation
1	KONG Extreme	Food enrichment	Natural rubber	S-XXL; weight guide	Inspect hollow rim	Check price
2	Goughnuts Ring	Supervised ring chewing	Natural rubber	Model and cross-section	Indicator varies by model	See options
3	West Paw Hurley	Fetch + chew	Zogoflex	XS 4.5 / S 6 / L 8.25 in	No stuffing cavity	See options
4	Nylabone DuraChew	Flavor variety	Hard nylon	Check exact Power Chew	Tooth-fracture risk	Check price
5	Benebone Wishbone	Paw-braced gnawing	Hard nylon	Tiny-Giant; weight limits	Not for extreme chewers	Check price