West Paw vs KONG – which dog toy is best?
The West Paw Hurley and the KONG Extreme are two of our favourite chew toys for destructive dogs. Both are designed to withstand heavy gnawing, yet they have different shapes, materials and play styles. This comparison breaks down those differences so you can choose the right toy for your dog’s preferences.
Comparison table
| Feature | West Paw Hurley | KONG Extreme |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Flexible Zogoflex rubber (BPA‑free, non‑toxic, floats) | Dense natural rubber |
| Shape | Bone‑shaped stick that floats | Hollow, stuffable cone |
| Best for | Dogs that enjoy fetch and water play | Power chewers that like to chew & eat slowly |
| Safety | Floats and can be thrown; backed by a manufacturer guarantee | Bounces unpredictably, reduces leverage; can be stuffed to extend chew time |
| Check price on Chewy | Check price on Chewy |
West Paw Hurley
This BPA‑free Zogoflex toy is shaped like a bone but constructed from West Paw’s ultra‑durable rubber. It floats, is dishwasher safe, and is gentle on teeth yet tough enough for enthusiastic chewers. Many dogs love to chase it on land or retrieve it from the water.
KONG Extreme
The classic KONG Extreme uses dense natural rubber with a hollow centre that can be stuffed with peanut butter, kibble or treats. The unpredictable bounce makes it fun for fetch, and stuffing it slows down power chewers for a longer, more engaging chew session.
Last updated: March 2026.